UNITED STATES
SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE COMMISSION
Washington, D.C. 20549
FORM 8-K
Current Report
Pursuant to Section 13 or 15(d)
of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934
Date of Report (Date of earliest event reported): January 14, 2004
OPTICAL CABLE CORPORATION
(Exact name of registrant as specified in its charter)
Virginia | 000-27022 | 54-1237042 | ||
(State or other jurisdiction of incorporation or organization) |
(Commission File Number) |
(I.R.S. Employer Identification Number) | ||
5290 Concourse Drive Roanoke, VA |
24019 (Zip Code) | |||
(Address of principal executive offices) |
(540) 265-0690
(Registrants telephone number, including area code)
Item 7. Financial Statements and Exhibits
(c) Exhibits
The following are filed as Exhibits to this Report.
Exhibit No. |
Description of Exhibit | |
99.1 |
Press release issued January 14, 2004 (FILED HEREWITH) | |
99.2 |
Transcript of earnings call on January 15, 2004 (FILED HEREWITH) |
Item 12, Results of Operations and Financial Condition
On January 14, 2004, Optical Cable Corporation issued a press release announcing its 2003 fourth quarter and year end sales and earnings. On January 15, 2004, Optical Cable Corporation had its earning call. The press release is attached hereto as Exhibit 99.1 and the transcript for our earnings call is attached as Exhibit 99.2.
SIGNATURES
Pursuant to the requirements of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934, the registrant has duly caused this report to be signed on its behalf by the undersigned hereunto duly authorized.
OPTICAL CABLE CORPORATION | ||||
By: |
/s/ NEIL D. WILKIN, JR. | |||
Name: Title: |
Neil D. Wilkin, Jr. President and Chief Executive Officer |
Dated: January 16, 2004
EXHIBIT INDEX
OPTICAL CABLE CORPORATION
Current report on Form 8-K
Exhibit No. |
Description of Exhibit | |
99.1 |
Press release issued January 14, 2004 (FILED HEREWITH) | |
99.2 |
Transcript of earnings call on January 15, 2004 (FILED HEREWITH) |
|
OPTICAL CABLE CORPORATION | ||
5290 Concourse Drive | ||
Roanoke, VA 24019 | ||
(Nasdaq NM: OCCF) | ||
www.occfiber.com | ||
AT THE COMPANY: |
AT FINANCIAL RELATIONS BOARD: | |
Neil Wilkin |
Marilynn Meek | |
President & CEO |
General Information | |
(540) 265-0690 |
(212) 445-8451 | |
investorrelations@occfiber.com |
mmeek@financialrelationsboard.com | |
Tracy Smith |
Peter Seltzberg | |
Vice President & CFO |
Analyst Information | |
(540) 265-0690 |
(212) 445-8457 | |
investorrelations@occfiber.com |
pseltzberg@financialrelationsboard.com |
FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE:
OPTICAL CABLE CORPORATION REPORTS
FOURTH QUARTER AND FISCAL 2003 FINANCIAL RESULTS
Net Income Up 11% Over Fiscal Year 2002
ROANOKE, VA, January 14, 2004 Optical Cable Corporation (Nasdaq NM: OCCF) today announced financial results for its fiscal fourth quarter and year ended October 31, 2003.
Fiscal Year 2003 Financial Results
The Company reported net income for fiscal year 2003 of $315,000, or $0.05 per diluted share, compared to net income of $284,000, or $0.04 per diluted share for fiscal year 2002. The 11.0% increase in net income was accomplished despite a 3.5% decrease in net sales to $41.1 million in fiscal year 2003 from $42.6 million for the prior year. On a year-to-date basis, Optical Cables gross profit margin was approximately the same as the prior year at 35.5% for fiscal year 2003 versus gross profit margin of 35.2% for fiscal year 2002.
In fiscal year 2003, the Company had an unusual non-cash charge of $862,000 resulting from the variable accounting treatment of warrants issued in connection with the shareholder class action settlement. This charge is included in income from operations.
Optical Cable Corp.Fourth Quarter 2003 Earnings Release
Page 2 of 5
Fourth Quarter 2003 Financial Results
Optical Cable reported net income of $405,000 or $0.07 per basic and diluted share for the fourth quarter of fiscal 2003 compared to net income of $326,000 or $0.05 per basic and diluted share for the same quarter last year.
Net sales for the fourth quarter of fiscal 2003 increased 7.5% to $11.3 million from $10.6 million for the same period last year. Net sales for the fourth quarter of fiscal year 2003 increased sequentially compared to the first three quarters of fiscal 2003, with net sales of $9.7 million in the first quarter, $9.8 million in the second quarter and $10.3 million in the third quarter. Management indicated that the pattern of net sales experienced during fiscal year 2003 may reflect a return to seasonality patterns experienced by the Company prior to fiscal year 2001. Specifically, net sales historically were relatively lower in the first half of each fiscal year and relatively higher in the second half of each fiscal year, which the Company believes may be partially due to the construction cycles and budgetary cycles of its customers.
Gross profit as a percentage of net sales for the fourth fiscal quarter of 2003 was 37.4% compared to 34.8% for the fourth fiscal quarter of 2002. Gross profit margins were 35.9%, 39.5% and 29.4% in the first, second and third quarters of 2003, respectively. The increase in the gross profit margin in the fourth quarter of 2003 compared to the fourth quarter of 2002 resulted primarily from the Companys ability to obtain lower pricing on certain raw materials coupled with a relative increase in product mix for products with higher margins.
Selling, general and administrative expenses (excluding shareholder litigation settlement expenses) (SG&A expenses) for the fourth quarter of fiscal 2003 increased 7.5 % to $3.8 million from $3.4 million for the same period last year. This compared to SG&A expenses of $3.3 million, $3.4 million and $2.9 million in the first, second and third quarters of fiscal year 2003, respectively. The increase in SG&A expenses during the fourth quarter of fiscal year 2003 compared to the same period last year resulted from increases in commissions, compensation costs and bad debt expense, partially offset by decreases in certain selling costs.
Management Comments
We are quite pleased with Optical Cables fourth quarter results and the results for fiscal 2003 as a whole. During a challenging year for the industry, Optical Cable was profitable. Further, by fiscal year end the Company had no outstanding balance on its bank line of credit and had $2.3 million in cash on hand, stated Mr. Neil Wilkin, President and CEO of Optical Cable Corporation.
We remain cautiously optimistic about future net sales and have seen some preliminary signs our markets are firming. However, it is still unclear when our markets will begin to show sustainable growth, added Mr. Wilkin.
Changes in Effective Tax Rate
The Companys effective tax rate is the amount of tax expense (or benefit) as a percentage of the Companys Generally Accepted Accounting Principles (GAAP) income (or loss) before taxes. During the fourth quarter of 2003, the Companys effective tax rate was 7.4%. During the fourth quarter of 2002 and for fiscal years 2003 and 2002, notwithstanding the income before income taxes, the Company reported income tax benefit for the period rather than income tax expense. The lower effective tax rate in the fourth quarter of fiscal 2003 and
Optical Cable Corp.Fourth Quarter 2003 Earnings Release
Page 3 of 5
the tax benefit, despite income before income taxes in the fourth quarter of 2002 and for fiscal years 2003 and 2002 is largely a result of the amount and timing of the tax benefits associated with the Companys estimated Extraterritorial Income Exclusion (EIE). The EIE excludes from federal taxable income a portion of the net profit realized from sales outside of the United States from products manufactured inside the United States.
Company Information
Optical Cable Corporation pioneered the design and production of special tight-buffered cables for the most demanding military field applications in the early 1980s. At its ISO 9001:2000 registered facility in Roanoke, Virginia, the Company manufactures a broad range of fiber optic cables for high bandwidth transmission of data, video, and audio communications over short to moderate distances. Optical Cable Corporations cables can be used both indoors and outdoors and utilize a unique tight-buffered coating process that provides excellent mechanical and environmental protection for the optical fiber. The current product portfolio is built on the evolution and refinement of the original fundamental technology into a comprehensive and versatile product line to provide end-users with significant value.
Further information about Optical Cable Corporation is available on the World Wide Web at www.occfiber.com.
FORWARD-LOOKING INFORMATION
This news release by Optical Cable Corporation (the Company) may contain certain forward-looking information within the meaning of the federal securities laws. The forward-looking information may include, among other information, (i) statements concerning the Companys outlook for the future, (ii) statements of belief, anticipation or expectation, (iii) future plans, strategies or anticipated events, and (iv) similar information and statements concerning matters that are not historical facts. Such forward-looking information is subject to risks and uncertainties that may cause actual events to differ materially from the Companys expectations. Factors that could cause or contribute to such differences include, but are not limited to, the level of sales to key customers, including distributors; the economic conditions affecting network service providers; corporate spending on information technology; actions by competitors; fluctuations in the price of raw materials (including optical fiber); the Companys dependence on a single manufacturing facility; the Companys ability to protect its proprietary manufacturing technology; market conditions influencing prices or pricing; the Companys dependence on a limited number of suppliers; an adverse outcome in litigation, claims and other actions, and potential litigation, claims and other actions, against the Company; an adverse outcome in regulatory reviews and audits and potential regulatory reviews and audits; an adverse change in laws and regulations associated with the extraterritorial income exclusion; adverse changes in state tax laws and/or positions taken by state taxing authorities affecting the Company; technological changes and introductions of new competing products; economic conditions that affect the telecommunications sector, certain technology sectors or the economy as a whole; terrorist attacks or acts of war, particularly given the acts of terrorism against the United States and subsequent military responses by the United States, and any potential future military conflicts; ability to retain key personnel; the impact of changes in accounting policies, including those by the Securities and Exchange Commission; changes in market demand, exchange rates, productivity, weather or market and economic conditions in the areas of the world in which the Company operates and markets its products, and the Companys success in managing the risks involved in the foregoing. The Company cautions readers that the foregoing list of important factors is not exclusive and the Company incorporates by reference those factors included in current reports on Form 8-K.
(Financial Tables Follow)
Optical Cable Corp.Fourth Quarter 2003 Earnings Release
Page 4 of 5
OPTICAL CABLE CORPORATION
CONDENSED STATEMENTS OF OPERATIONS
(thousands, except per share data)
(unaudited)
Three Months Ended October 31, |
Twelve Months Ended October 31, |
|||||||||||||||
2003 |
2002 |
2003 |
2002 |
|||||||||||||
Net sales |
$ | 11,349 | $ | 10,555 | $ | 41,114 | $ | 42,598 | ||||||||
Cost of goods sold |
7,109 | 6,880 | 26,505 | 27,607 | ||||||||||||
Gross profit |
4,240 | 3,675 | 14,609 | 14,991 | ||||||||||||
Selling, general and administrative expenses |
3,756 | 3,350 | 13,309 | 13,603 | ||||||||||||
Shareholder litigation settlement expense |
| 6 | 871 | 997 | ||||||||||||
Loss on impairment of machinery and equipment |
| | 117 | | ||||||||||||
Income from operations |
484 | 319 | 312 | 391 | ||||||||||||
Interest expense, net |
(47 | ) | (31 | ) | (160 | ) | (184 | ) | ||||||||
Other, net |
1 | (6 | ) | 40 | 9 | |||||||||||
Other expense, net |
(46 | ) | (37 | ) | (120 | ) | (175 | ) | ||||||||
Income before income taxes |
438 | 282 | 192 | 216 | ||||||||||||
Income tax expense (benefit) |
33 | (44 | ) | (123 | ) | (68 | ) | |||||||||
Net income |
$ | 405 | $ | 326 | $ | 315 | $ | 284 | ||||||||
Net income per share |
||||||||||||||||
Basic and diluted |
$ | 0.07 | $ | 0.05 | $ | 0.05 | $ | 0.04 | ||||||||
Weighted average shares outstanding |
||||||||||||||||
Basic |
5,455 | 6,929 | 5,736 | 6,929 | ||||||||||||
Diluted |
5,533 | 6,929 | 5,744 | 6,929 | ||||||||||||
-MORE-
Optical Cable Corp.Fourth Quarter 2003 Earnings Release
Page 5 of 5
OPTICAL CABLE CORPORATION
CONDENSED BALANCE SHEET DATA
(thousands)
(unaudited)
Assets | October 31, 2003 |
October 31, 2002 | ||||
Cash |
$ | 2,337 | $ | 747 | ||
Trade accounts receivable, net of allowance for doubtful accounts |
7,688 | 7,795 | ||||
Inventories |
6,625 | 9,412 | ||||
Other current assets |
1,178 | 1,829 | ||||
Total current assets |
$ | 17,828 | $ | 19,783 | ||
Non-current assets |
12,357 | 12,891 | ||||
Total assets |
$ | 30,185 | $ | 32,674 | ||
Liabilities and Shareholders Equity |
||||||
Total current liabilities |
$ | 3,551 | $ | 4,304 | ||
Other non-current liabilities |
| 166 | ||||
Total liabilities |
3,551 | 4,470 | ||||
Total shareholders equity |
26,634 | 28,204 | ||||
Total liabilities and shareholders equity |
$ | 30,185 | $ | 32,674 | ||
###
Exhibit 99.2
OPTICAL CABLE CORPORATION, #565595
Financial Relations Board
January 15, 2004, 9:00 a.m. ET
Chairperson: Marilyn Meek
Operator |
Good morning, ladies and gentlemen, and welcome to the Optical Cable fourth quarter earnings conference call. At this time, all participants are in a listen-only mode. Following todays presentation, instructions will be given for the question and answer session. If anyone needs assistance at any time during todays conference, please press the star followed by the zero. As a reminder, this conference is being recorded today, Thursday, January 15, 2004. |
I would now like to turn the conference over to Ms. Marilyn Meek from the Financial Relations Board. Please go ahead, maam. |
M. Meek |
Thank you. Good morning and thank you all for participating on Optical Cable Corporations fourth quarter of fiscal 2003 conference call. By this time everyone should have obtained a copy of the earnings release. However, if you havent, please call my office at the Financial Relations Board, 212-445-8453 and well fax or email a copy to you immediately. |
On the call with us today is Neil Wilkin, President and Chief Executive Officer of Optical Cable Corporation, as well as other members of senior management. |
Before we begin Id like to remind everyone this call may contain forward looking statements that involve risks and uncertainties. The actual future results of Optical Cable Corporation may differ materially due to a number of factors including but not limited to those factors set forth in detail in the forward looking statement section of yesterdays press release. These cautionary statements apply to the contents of the internet webcast on www.fulldisclosure.com as well as todays call. |
Id like to now turn the call over to Neil Wilkin. Neil, please begin. |
N. Wilkin |
Thank you, Marilyn, and good morning. Joining me here today at Optical Cable Corporations offices are Charlie Carson, our Senior Vice President of Marketing and Strategy, Luke Huybrechts, our Senior Vice President of Sales, and Tracy Smith, our Chief Financial Officer. |
Ill start with a few introductory remarks. We will then review some of the financial results for the fourth quarter and for the fiscal year and finally well answer as many of your questions as we can. |
OPTICAL CABLE CORPORATION | Page 1 | |
Ill preface my comments by reminding everyone that Optical Cable Corporation, like a number of other companies does not provide specific earnings guidance; however, I will say we remain cautiously optimistic about the future of net sales and have seen some preliminary signs that our markets are firming. However, it is still unclear when our markets will begin to show sustainable growth. |
Additionally, the pattern of net sales weve experienced during fiscal year 2003 may reflect a return to seasonality patterns experienced by the company prior to fiscal year 2001. Specifically, prior to fiscal year 2001, net sales historically have been relatively low in the first half of each fiscal year and relatively higher in the second half of each fiscal year which could partly be due to construction cycles and budgetary cycles of our customers. We believe we will see a similar pattern in fiscal 2004. |
We also believe theres been some pent up demand due to lower IT expenditures in the past and as companies begin to spend for previously postponed capital projects, this could favorably affect our top line. |
Now lets review the results for the fourth quarter and the year. |
For the fourth quarter of fiscal 2003, the company reported net income of $405,000 or 7 cents per share. As a result the company reported net income for fiscal year 2003 of $315,000 or 5 cents per share. |
In fiscal 2003, net income was up approximately 11% over fiscal year 2002. In fiscal year 2003, the company had an unusual non-cash charge of $862,000 before taxes resulting from the variable accounting treatment of warrants issued in connection with the shareholder class action settlement. This charge was included in income from operations prior to Q4 and did not affect Q4 results. |
You will recall we issued 250,000 warrants with an exercise price of $4.88 per share in connection with the shareholder litigation settlement in September of 2002. As weve stated in previous calls, generally accepted accounting principles require that the value of these warrants to be adjusted at each reporting period until certain conditions are met including the registration of shares to be issued upon exercise of the warrants, a condition that was satisfied during Q3 2003. |
As a result of this quarterly adjustment required by GAAP, the company recognized charges included in income from operations through Q3 2003 and for fiscal year 2003 totalling $862,000. The fair value of the warrants for purposes of this adjustment was determined using a Black-Scholes model. |
As we indicated in prior quarters, no additional charges with respect to the |
OPTICAL CABLE CORPORATION | Page 2 | |
warrants would be incurred after Q3 2003; additionally, during 2003 the fair value of the warrants previously expensed and accrued as in accrued shareholder litigation liability or reclassified to permanent equity in accordance with GAAP. |
In fiscal year 2002, the company incurred $997,000 in connection with shareholder litigation settlement expenses of which $320,000 represented a fair value of the warrants to be issued for GAAP purposes. |
With respect to our bank debt, we are pleased to report that as of October 31, 2003, we have no outstanding debt balance on our bank line of credit and at year end we have a cash balance of over $2.3 million. At the end of the third quarter our bank debt totalled $244,000, down from just over $1 million at the end of the second quarter and a little over $2 million at the end of the first quarter. |
Net sales for the fourth quarter of fiscal 2003 increased 7.5% to $11.3 million from $10.6 million for the same period last year. Net sales for the fourth quarter of fiscal year 2003 also increased sequentially with net sales of $9.7 million in Q1, $9.8 million in Q2 and $10.3 million in Q3 of 2003. |
Gross profit as a percentage of net sales for the fourth quarter was 37.4% compared to 34.8% for the fourth quarter of 2002. Gross profit margins were 35.9%, 39.5% and 29.4% in the first, second and third quarters of 2003, respectively. |
The increase in gross profit margin in the fourth quarter 2003 compared to the fourth quarter 2002 resulted primarily from our ability to obtain certain lower pricing on raw materials coupled with a relative increase in product mix for products with higher margins. |
You may recall that during the third quarter our gross profit margin was negatively impacted by a charge of $166,000 resulting from a change in estimate with respect to net realizable value of certain finished goods inventory and a charge of $133,000 resulting from a change in estimate regarding the collectability of a refund associated with raw material purchases. |
Because of the two unusual charges mentioned, our gross margins during our third quarter were lower than our expectations for the year. |
Over the longer term we expect gross margins to be in the 34-35% range. |
SG&A expenses excluding shareholder litigation settlement expenses for the fourth quarter of fiscal year 2003 increased 7.5% to $3.8 million from $3.4 million for the same period last year. This compared to SG&A expenses |
OPTICAL CABLE CORPORATION | Page 3 |
which ranged from between $2.9 million to $3.4 million during the first three quarters of the year. The increase in SG&A expenses during the fourth quarter of fiscal year 2003 compared to the same period last year resulted from increases in commissions, compensation costs and bad debt expense partially offset by decreases in certain selling costs. |
We continue to carefully monitor all of our expenses including SG&A in order to keep costs down but also were working towards building a stronger company for the future. We have added appropriate personnel and resources that will permit us to increase sales and our profitability over the long term. |
Since our effective tax rate has significant impact on reporting net income for the fourth quarter as well as for the year, Id like to comment on taxes. During the fourth quarter of 2003 our effective tax rate was 7.4% compared to an expected tax rate of 34% based on the U.S. federal statutory income tax rate plus a state tax component. Additionally, for fiscal year 2003 despite positive income before income taxes, we reported income tax benefit for the period rather than income tax expense. |
A number of factors impacted deviations from the actual effective tax rate from the expected statutory tax rate including state tax effects, tax treatment that differs from GAAP and our extra-territorial income exclusion, also referred to as Extraterritorial Income Exclusion. |
The EIE excludes from federal taxable income a portion of net profits realized from sales outside of the United States for products manufactured inside the United States resulting in a tax benefit that is recognized for book purposes. The amounts and timing of the tax benefits associated with our EIE are the primary factors contributing to fluctuations in our effective tax rate. |
In 2004 there will be an additional compensation in developing the effective tax rate. Some of you may be aware that the World Trade Organization has ruled against the United States EIE regime and in the ruling the World Trade Organization gave permission to the European Union to sanction tariffs to U.S. products if the EIE regime is not repealed by March 31, 2004. There are two proposed bills that could repeal the EIE regime. Currently the proposed bills will not be retroactive, giving exporting taxpayers full EIE benefit for 2003. |
I would like to comment briefly on another matterthe bankruptcy proceedings of one of our former distributors. During fiscal years 2002 and 2001, Optical Cable wrote off a total of $2.2 million in an uncollectible account receivable related to the bankruptcy of Anicom. Additionally, you will recall as previously disclosed that Optical Cable had a preference action brought against it for payments received from Anicom prior to Anicoms |
OPTICAL CABLE CORPORATION | Page 4 |
bankruptcy filing. |
Our view of the outcome of the preference proceeding against Optical Cable has not changed from what we disclosed in the third quarter. However, with respect to the amounts of the accounts receivable write off, there appears to be some chance of a possible recovery from the Anicom bankruptcy estate. At this time we are unable to provide any information about the possible amount of any recovery and cannot be certain as to whether there will be any recovery at all. I will say that we have had offers which have since expired to sell $1.9 million of our claim against the Anicom bankrupt estate for up to 20 cents on the dollar. |
At this time Optical Cable has decided not to sell its claim in the Anicom bankruptcy proceeding. The recovery, if any at all, will only be recognized when a payment is received in accordance with GAAP. |
Finally, Optical Cables management remains committed to both growing the company for the future and increasing profits and we are taking the necessary actions to ensure that we achieve those goals. Our efforts include both sales initiatives of various types as well as improvements to our operations and other infrastructure. |
At this time well be happy to answer questions. Marilyn, if you would please have the operator indicate the instructions for participants to call in their questions, Id appreciate it. |
M. Meek |
Sure, Neil, thank you. Jeff will give the instructions in one minute but first let me start off by saying we are taking questions only from professional investors, analysts and fund managers and in the interest of time, each person wishing to ask questions will be permitted to ask two questions initially. If there is time following everyone given this opportunity, we will allow for follow up questions. Jeff, if you could give the instructions. |
Operator |
Thank you, maam. Ladies and gentlemen, at this time we will begin the question and answer session. If you have a question, please press the star followed by the one on your pushbutton phone. If you would like to decline from the polling process, please press the star followed by the two. You will hear a 3-tone prompt acknowledging your selection and your questions will be polled in the order they are received. If you are using speaker equipment, you will need to lift the handset before pressing the numbers. |
Our first question comes from Matthew Curtis. Please state your company affiliation followed by your question. |
M. Curtis |
Im with Kenny Securities. Good morning, everyone. Neil, just a couple quick questions. Do you have any expectation that well be seeing any |
OPTICAL CABLE CORPORATION | Page 5 | |
significant announcements with regard customer activity coming out in the near future? |
N. Wilkin |
No, Matthew. We have heard recently that theres some rumors of significant activity but if there were something that was significant that we were required to disclose, we would have disclosed that. |
M. Curtis |
Okay. Then you mentioned that your margins improved this quarter as higher margin products were sold and an improvement in your cost of goods sold. The higher margin products, could you elaborate a little bit on that? Was that multimode fibers specifically over single mode and do you see that as sustainable? |
N. Wilkin |
I dont think the margins we saw in Q4 are going to be sustainable over a longer period of time. We really expect the margin to be in the 34-35% range as Ive previously indicated. We havent talked in detail about single mode versus multimode mix but we did have a slight decrease in single mode sales during the fourth quarter relative to multimode sales. I was just checking as I was answering you. Thats made a little bit of difference in the fourth quarter, but over the long term we expect the rate to be in the 34, 35% range barring any other industry changes or pricing changes. |
M. Curtis |
Okay, thanks, Neil. |
N. Wilkin |
Thank you. |
Operator |
Thank you. Our next question comes from Richard Friary. Please state your company name followed by your question. |
R. Friary |
Delphi Management. A couple of questions. One, do you think somewhere off in the future this business can do a mid-teens return on equity. And two, can you just talk about your positioning versus some of your competitors and how you see the competitive landscape right now? |
N. Wilkin |
Sure. I think the industry as it is currently just coming out of a big downturn, its been a difficult time and for OCC in particular we came through some other matters that weve successfully overcome and so relative to our competitors, our returns and the fact that were even profitable is a big accomplishment. |
As sales growth increases we expect to see greater profitability and a higher return on equity. Im not prepared to comment on exactly what that return would be. |
With respect to the competitive landscape, theres a lot of cable |
OPTICAL CABLE CORPORATION | Page 6 | |
manufacturers out there that we compete with. As you know, were in the LAN premises, the LAN premises market primarily so some of those competitors compete with us in our markets as well as also participating in the long haul telco market. I can name some specific competitors if you want. Is that what youd like? |
R. Friary |
Not so much specific competitors but what are your advantages and disadvantages against some of these people? |
N. Wilkin |
Optical Cable has always prided itself in providing a product that has superior performance characteristics relative to our competitors. A classic example of that is the military tactical cable that were so well known for. Our product is known for being more rugged, its known for being higher performance characteristics overall and because of those characteristics, were able to sell value in the markets, particularly in markets where those sorts of characteristics are required. |
In some cases its in harsher environments but in other cases its simply where someone is installing a product in a building and they like the fact that theyre better able to terminate, more easily able to terminate the connections as well as dont have to worry as much about scuffing up the cable or putting it through some stress during installation. So thats what we really focus on. Were not known as the low priced competitor. In fact our prices generally command a slight premium over the rest of the market because of these product characteristics. |
R. Friary |
Alright. You mentioned Ill end it here but youre able to obtain lower pricing on certain raw materials and then theres an increase in product mix for products with higher margins. Do you have an advantage over some of your competitors on those two counts? Are you able to make that higher margin product better, more attractive to your customers and do you do a better job of buying certain raw materials than your competitors? |
N. Wilkin |
I dont know if we do a better job of buying raw materials. I think clearly I answered the first part of the question with respect to the fact that our product has certain characteristics to make it easier. |
The mix between single mode and multimode doesnt have anything to do with the product being different from our competitors, its simply the fact that the margins are better on multimode. |
With respect to purchases, we do command given our size in the marketplace, the ability to obtain attractive pricing, but I cant really compare that to what our competitors are able to get for a number of reasons including the fact that a lot of them dont make as many disclosures as we do. |
OPTICAL CABLE CORPORATION | Page 7 | |
R. Friary |
Thank you very much. |
N. Wilkin |
Sure. |
Operator |
Thank you. The next question comes from Kevin Wenck. Please state your company name followed by your question. |
K. Wenck |
Polynous Capital Management. Good morning, Neil. |
N. Wilkin |
Good morning. |
K. Wenck |
The first question is the drop in inventories. Very impressive what youre able to do there. It might be helpful though if you had a breakdown before the K was issued as to how it was distributed by raw materials, WIP and finished goods. |
N. Wilkin |
I dont have that breakdown in front of me, Kevin. I take your point. Maybe in the future we can add that to our press release because I think it would be helpful information. Classifications on the balance sheet sometimes are adjusted after earnings release but before we end up issuing the 10K. Thats the reason we dont have as much balance sheet detail in our press release. |
We really have made a concerted effort to try to make sure that weve optimized our inventory levels. Its important for us that we maintain a proper mix of products to meet our customer needs but also avoid excess inventory levels. |
At the end of each quarter we perform a detailed analysis of our inventory in order to ensure that we are properly valuing it. So thats the process that we expect to continue. I cant guaranty that inventories, particularly if market conditions change, are going to continue at lower levels. But we do constantly monitor that and are careful not to add inventory that we dont believe is going to have an appropriate turn rate. |
K. Wenck |
Still an 18% sequential drop is pretty impressive. Can you offer us some color as to where it might have come from? |
N. Wilkin |
I really cant offer you a lot of detail at this time. I dont think that I should do that. But it is if youll give me a second, maybe Ill provide you some information with respect to where it came from in the breakdown between finished goods and raw materials. But this is just the process of making sure that what were manufacturing is to what we believe the customer demands and also trying to liquidate some of the excess inventory thats resulted from the period that we had starting a year and a half ago where the market was down by so much. |
OPTICAL CABLE CORPORATION | Page 8 | |
I can tell you we had a drop in both raw materials and in finished goods. Finished goods dropped about (and Im rounding here) about $500,000 and raw materials dropped about $300,000. Work in process dropped even more than both of those. |
K. Wenck |
Okay, thats very helpful. The next question is in the SG&A area. As you know yourself the number has been fluctuating quite a bit. You mentioned compensation as one of the factors leading to the increase this quarter. Is this possibly bonus compensation at year end given that its been a pretty good year for you that ended up just hitting in Q4 or is this ongoing increased levels of compensation for new hires or Any comments on that would be helpful. |
N. Wilkin |
Sure, theres a number of different factors. One is bad debt expense. And we saw an increase in bad debt expense of about $280,000 in Q4 versus Q3 and that was mainly the result of significant charge, $170,000 related to a foreign customer that entered into receivership in the fourth quarter. We had previously included a reserve in accounts receivable but our judgment changed when they entered receivership and have since written off the entire accounts receivable. The $170,000 relates to that, the additional charge that hit the fourth quarter. |
You also mentioned the fact that weve been adding employees and thats correct. At the end of fiscal year 2002 we had 152 employees, at the end of fiscal 2003 we have 160. Weve had some people leave, weve been adding some individuals particularly in the sales area where weve tried to expand our coverage domestically and somewhat internationally although the international adds are really on a straight commission basis, so it really shouldnt affect SG&A costs directly except with the corresponding increase in sales. |
Then the last item that you mentioned is exactly correct actually but I want to say a few words about it. During fiscal year 2003 Optical Cable in consultation with an independent consulting firm adopted a management incentive plan. And we described this plan at least with respect to the executive officers in last years proxy statement. So Id refer you to that disclosure. |
The plan, however, includes all members of management having departmental responsibilities, essentially director and above and is based on pay for performance. Previously as was true for the executives prior to the option of this new plan and before Id taken action to revise it, there had been plans in place where people were based on rewarded for sales levels and so this pay for performance is really based on a number of financial performance measures including EBITDA. Most of its quantitative, but |
OPTICAL CABLE CORPORATION | Page 9 | |
some of it is qualitative targets. |
As Ive just said, this plan replaced the other monthly and year end incentives that existed previously with an incentive based on the performance by participants over the entire year. The expenses under the plan are accrued quarterly based on performance through each quarter and therefore as financial performance improves, the costs can increase. However, its not something thats discretionary except with respect to the qualitative portion which is really an evaluation of how people did based on a set bonus opportunity. So the cost is really determined or the plans really determined up front and so as financial performance improves, you can see an increase in expense related to this plan and as it decreases you see a decrease in expense, but its not something where there were a bunch on bonuses loaded into and not previously accrued into the fourth quarter. |
But because of the financial performance in the fourth quarter in particular, because remember up until the third quarter we had still shown a loss, there was about $150,000 that was accrued in Q4. |
K. Wenck |
$150,000 above what the accrual might have been in Q3 or $150 total in Q4? |
N. Wilkin |
$150 in addition to what was previously accrued through Q3. |
K. Wenck |
If you back out the additions to bad debt and you back out the additional incentive accrual in Q4, a normalized level of SG&A at this point might be in lets say the $3.2 to $3.4 million a quarter range? |
N. Wilkin |
Yes. I mean the target that I use, Kevin, is normally around 3.3 to 3.4 but what Id also say is we have in looking at making some additional hires and weve made one hire in particular. John Dyer has joined Optical Cable. He is overseeing our operations. Hes at a senior director level and essentially a plant manager type position. So there are some costs that may cause that 3.3 to 3.4 to inch up slightly. Maybe a better range at this point would be 3.4 to 3.5. Is that ? |
K. Wenck |
Alright. Thanks for your help. |
N. Wilkin |
Subject to Im trying to give you as much information as I can, Kevin. But recognize that were continuing to build and that number could inch up. Im not trying to guaranty that number for you. |
K. Wenck |
No, I realize that its just part of a discussion. Thanks, Neil. |
N. Wilkin |
Youre welcome. |
OPTICAL CABLE CORPORATION | Page 10 | |
Operator |
Thank you. Ladies and gentlemen, if you have an additional question, please press the star followed by the one. And as a reminder, if youre using speaker equipment, youll need to lift the handset before pressing the numbers. |
The next question is a follow up question from Matthew Curtis. Please go ahead. |
M. Curtis |
Hi again, Neil. Just a couple of quick follow ups. With regards to your gross profits, as we move forward and we move a little bit closer to that 34 to 35% range, is it going to be in your opinion at this point anyway that costs, in regards to your cost of goods sold coming back up to where theyve been in the last couple of quarters or is it going to be the product mix shifting back to less higher margin products? |
N. Wilkin |
Our gross margin really can fluctuate as has been seen in the past based on product mix and other factors. So that 34 to 35% is really a target that I think is relatively appropriate. Im hoping and we always work towards trying to beat a number like that. But from the 34 to 35% range, I feel like were really doing the job were supposed to be doing. |
M. Curtis |
I understand. Let me ask it a different way. How sustainable is the cost structure on your products that youre purchasing in your cost of goods sold right now? |
N. Wilkin |
I think like all cable manufacturers fiber prices have been relatively low and that could change because fiber prices are about as low as they could possibly get at this point given the fact that theres so much overcapacity. But other costs have been increasing. Like a lot of companies we saw increases in healthcare costs this year and that impacts cost of goods sold to the extent that it relates to manufacturing, the manufacturing employees. Weve also seen increases in other raw material costs that are related to oil prices going up. So its really a mixed bag. |
M. Curtis |
I understand. As were about 10 days out from the end of this quarter along with your cautious optimism mentioned in your press release, is there any reason to suspect that we would not see a sequential increase in your revenue next quarter? |
N. Wilkin |
I think theres every reason to believe that we would not see it because of the seasonality factor that we have. |
M. Curtis |
Youd mentioned EIE a little bit earlier and some of the difficulties were seeing on a macro level with that. Assuming things stay as they are now, do you have some kind of anticipation for what your tax rate might be for the next fiscal year? |
OPTICAL CABLE CORPORATION | Page 11 | |
N. Wilkin |
Im going to let Tracy address that question. I dont know how specific she can give you because we really havent I dont think shes really calculated an expected tax rate given these new developments prospectively. |
T. Smith |
Thats right, Neil. It would be a moot point at this time for us to calculate what we think it would be without these other factors and we do look at this each quarter. The exclusion is calculated by a complex analysis of all export sales and profits for the year, orderly fluctuations in export sales and profitability. Total sales and profitability create changes in the exclusion and tax benefit on a quarter basis. So while we try to true that up every quarter and make sure that its appropriate, theres always the possibility that theres some changes in judgment that go along with that effective tax rate. |
So given the current legislative environment related to the EIE, we are going to be looking at it very closely at the end of this first quarter, but we have not done that yet. |
N. Wilkin |
The other thing we can say from a long term standpoint, particularly as sales increase and profitability improves and EIE doesnt impact our tax calculations as much, what would you say sort of a standard effective tax rate would be? |
T. Smith |
In the past, 35% has been a standard when we had a higher level of income before taxes. |
N. Wilkin |
Does that help? |
M. Curtis |
Yes, it does very much. And then lastly on sort of an industry level, have you seen any drivers that would continue to generate growth in multimode fiber over single mode fiber? Are there any applications or equipment coming online that might suggest one might sell better than the other in the coming future? |
N. Wilkin |
There are a number of different factors that make it exciting to be in the fiber business over the long term. Im going to have Charlie jump in and mention a couple of them. But before I do, some of them are the pent up IT demand that weve seen and theres a constant demand for increased bandwidth. Applications are more and more becoming bandwidth-intensive. |
Was there anything you wanted to add, Charlie? |
C. Carson |
I think that pretty much sums it up. The point being if you go back just a few years to have even imagined that you would have one gig or 10 gig capacity at a desktop would not have been possible and today that is being installed. So those kinds of bandwidth demands are going to continue to be good for our industry. |
OPTICAL CABLE CORPORATION | Page 12 | |
N. Wilkin |
Paralleling that, a lot of the costs of the equipment necessary to implement a fiber solution to the desk for example is coming down. Do you want to comment on that? |
C. Carson |
Absolutely, in fact for new construction there are some economics that would indicate that fiber is advantaged over older technologies. |
N. Wilkin |
The models that Charlies referring to include cost savings relative to smaller telecommunication closets, a reduction in the number of telecommunications closets for example. So if youre just looking at equipment costs. |
C. Carson |
And the OE conversions, optical, electrical conversions in those closets and the air conditioning and the floor space and all of those kinds of things. |
M. Curtis |
Okay so with equipment costs beginning to come down and demand for overall bandwidth increasing, is it likely that we will begin to see a greater shift to more single mode fiber installations? |
N. Wilkin |
Did you say fiber generally or single mode? |
M. Curtis |
Well single mode specifically. |
N. Wilkin |
The applications weve been talking about, you can have a multimode solution to the desk and it provides the type of bandwidth weve been talking about. The problem is that for years people have been predicting this huge acceleration in fiber deployment in the LAN premise applications, so we all know that its eventually coming, but when its going to happen is still up for debate. Is it short term or is it long term? |
Some of the pent up demand you have on IT spending may first, for example be spent on computer equipment and software upgrades and people may defer purchases to improve their networking capacity. So theres a number of factors there.
C. Carson |
Just one comment on the single mode versus multimode. Multimode will retain an advantage over single mode for quite a long time because of the larger core diameter and the ease and lower cost of connectivity, those types of issues. That also helps with the cost of the electronics being lower. |
N. Wilkin |
Exactly. |
M. Curtis |
Okay, very good. Thank you, gentlemen. |
N. Wilkin |
Youre welcome. |
OPTICAL CABLE CORPORATION | Page 13 |
Operator |
Thank you. Our next question comes from Kevin Wenck. Please state your company name followed by your question. |
K. Wenck |
Polynous Capital Management. Neil, if you have it, a sales split between domestic and international for the quarter and between direct and distribution. |
N. Wilkin |
We dont ... we sell almost every ... let me answer the second question first. We sell really almost everything through distribution. The exceptions are original equipment manufacturers and sales like that which is very traditional in our industry. I dont have that split in front of me. Tracys pulling the split on domestic versus international. Id sort of prefer to wait until we put that in the 10K because I dont think weve reviewed that number yet, Kevin. Historically weve been at about 20 to 25% international versus the rest domestic. |
K. Wenck |
Another way of asking a question on the direct versus distribution, any changing trends in the quarter where more of it went through some channels versus others or anything like that happen? |
N. Wilkin |
No. In fact Im encouraged by the fact that we are ... we spent a lot of time building relationships with key distributors and those efforts are ongoing. During the last year and a half those relationships with a number of our key distributors have improved significantly. |
K. Wenck |
The next question would be the helpful effects on gross margins from the raw material purchase, was that fiber or was it other raw materials during the quarter? |
N. Wilkin |
What I was referring to with respect to the fourth quarter was really fiber. |
K. Wenck |
Was that a one time deal that was available opportunistically or was that a renegotiated pricing arrangement that might go on for a few more quarters? |
N. Wilkin |
Were constantly negotiating our prices but I think that I wouldnt expect to continue to see that. Its not a situation where we purchased a quantity or did something outside of our normal purchase methodology. So its not one time opportunistic purchases in that respect. These are just normal standard purchases from our normal standard suppliers. But what Id also say is I wouldnt expect that ... Im not sure how long those price advantages are sustainable. I think thats anyones guess. So I wouldnt count on it. Id go back to the numbers that I previously referred to with respect to gross margins. |
K. Wenck |
Given that during the downturn there was a good deal of inventory that was |
OPTICAL CABLE CORPORATION | Page 14 |
revalued to lower levels but now that were turning up a little bit, were gross margins helped at all during the quarter by some of that inventory being sold at market prices today that were a lot, higher than, I wont say a lot but higher than where the inventories have been revalued down to? |
N. Wilkin |
Similar to excess capacity and so much inventory thats been sloshing around the industry, while we continue to make efforts to minimize any inventory whether it had been written off to a lower cost of market previously or not. Those efforts will continue but were not seeing the huge bump up in sales because of that or a corresponding increase in gross margins. |
K. Wenck |
So you didnt sell a bunch of stuff that had been revalued to a pretty low level at prices higher than you might have expected during the quarter? |
T. Smith |
Not to a significant extent. |
N. Wilkin |
Not to an extent that would affect the margins significantly. |
K. Wenck |
Thats how Cisco has helped their gross margins for about 2 years now. One other question. A cap ex budget in rough numbers for this current fiscal year? |
N. Wilkin |
I dont have that for you right now, Kevin, so I cant really comment. We do continue to look at purchases but we havent in the past had a very extensive capital expenditure need. |
K. Wenck |
Hows the automation project going? |
N. Wilkin |
The automation project is ... were actually very pleased with the way its going. Its moving along nicely and as we ... as it continues, we expect to see benefits in the future. I wouldnt specifically attribute the automation project to the results in the fourth quarter either. |
K. Wenck |
One question for Charlie. Im interested in the 10 gig rollout myself for a lot of other reasons. But how much activity are you seeing there, Charlie, in terms of network backbones being upgraded to 10 gig? |
C. Carson |
Thats an interesting question, Kevin, because theres two parts to a building, the backbones and the horizontals. As background, most of the verticals in a building are fiber today. We are seeing some conversion of that to 1 gig and 10 gig. It is a very small percentage right now both for us and the marketplace in general. But the people that are installing that are doing it in anticipation of bandwidth requirements or because of real requirements. And in most cases that is in new construction and it is going to the desk so the enduser realizes that bandwidth capacity. |
OPTICAL CABLE CORPORATION | Page 15 |
K. Wenck |
Okay, thanks. |
N. Wilkin |
Thank you. I was going to ask Kevin if he wanted to buy any. I wasnt sure if it was for an installation that you might have in mind. |
K. Wenck |
No, just keeping track of all the claims of the networking companies that say its going to be a big market for them this year. |
Operator |
Thank you, sir. Ladies and gentlemen, if you have an additional question, please press the star followed by the one. |
At this time we have no further questions. Id like to turn the conference back over for any concluding comments.
N. Wilkin |
Thank you and thank you all for your questions. We tried to be as open as we can and provided you with information that hopefully youll find useful in your analysis. I look forward to talking to you next quarter. Thank you for your time. |
Operator |
Thank you, sir. Ladies and gentlemen, this concludes the Optical Cable fourth quarter earnings conference call. If you would like to listen to a replay of todays conference, please dial 1-800-405-2236 and you will need to enter the passcode of 565595 followed by the pound sign. Thank you for participating in todays conference, you may now disconnect. |
OPTICAL CABLE CORPORATION | Page 16 |